Below is a proposed A/B testing roadmap based on the optimization points identified in this audit. Each test is assigned a potential lift, which is an estimate of the conversion rate increase if the test is successful. The final expected conversion lift is calculated based on a 40% win rate, which is a typical average for a well-structured A/B testing program.

The current headline, "Paper's Dead. Notarize Online.", is short and memorable, but it functions more as a clever tagline than a powerful value proposition. It tells visitors what BlueNotary does at a high level, but it fails to communicate the specific, compelling outcomes a potential customer will achieve by using the service. B2B buyers, who are the primary audience for your Business and Real Estate segments, are driven by KPIs and ROI. They need to see immediately how your solution will improve their business, whether that's by saving time, reducing costs, or increasing efficiency. The current headline creates a messaging gap by not addressing these core motivations from the very first impression.

Rewrite the headline to focus on a strong, quantifiable business outcome that directly addresses the pain points of your target customer profiles. According to our past A/B tests on B2B websites, headlines that communicate a clear and quantifiable value proposition consistently outperform generic or clever alternatives. The goal is to answer the visitor's primary question: "How will this make my business better?"

Here are a few examples, tailored to your different customer segments:

These revised headlines immediately communicate a tangible benefit (time savings, faster closings, earning potential) that is far more compelling to a motivated buyer.

The homepage currently lacks immediate, high-impact social proof above the fold. While there is a testimonial further down the page and a claim of being "Trusted by millions," B2B buyers are inherently skeptical and require more concrete evidence to feel secure in their decision-making process. You have a 4.9-star rating on Trustpilot from over 2,000 reviews, which is a powerful asset that is not being leveraged on the most valuable real estate of your website.

Incorporate prominent social proof in the hero section to immediately address buyer skepticism and build credibility. Our A/B testing data consistently shows that placing social proof above the fold significantly increases conversion rates. Here's how you can do it:

The current hero image is a stock photo of a woman holding a phone. While visually appealing, it does nothing to communicate what BlueNotary is or how it works.

Replace the current stock photo with an appealing snapshot of the BlueNotary platform in action. Our past A/B tests on B2B SaaS/platform websites have consistently shown that showing the product in the hero section wins against abstract imagery or stock images. A visual of your user-friendly interface would immediately demonstrate the simplicity and efficiency of your service, making the concept of online notarization tangible and less intimidating for new users.

The hero section currently presents visitors with five competiing calls-to-action: "NOTARIZE A DOCUMENT NOW", "FOR BUSINESS-NOTARIZE NOW", "FOR REAL ESTATE-ECLOSE NOW", and "FOR NOTARIES-SIGN UP FOR FREE". This creates decision fatigue and can confuse visitors, leading to inaction.

Simplify the hero section to a single, clear primary CTA and a secondary, less prominent CTA. The primary CTA should be the main action you want users to take, such as "Notarize a Document Now". The secondary CTA could be a "Book a Demo" button for business and real estate clients. The audience segmentation can be moved to a dedicated section further down the page or handled through a clearer, more visually distinct navigation.

By simplifying the CTAs, you guide visitors toward the most important conversion actions, reducing friction and increasing the likelihood of them taking the desired step.

Currently, social proof is concentrated in a single testimonial section toward the bottom of the page. Based on heatmaps, more than 50% of visitors drop off before the first two sections.

Frontload social proof higher up on the page, and place throughout the entire page if possible.

The eClosing section headline, "Real estate closings no longer need to be slow," is good but could be more powerful by quantifying the speed improvement and tying it to a specific business outcome. In our past B2B A/B tests, quantifiable outcomes have significantly outperformed general claims.

Revise the headline to include a quantifiable outcome that speaks to the KPIs of real estate professionals. For example:

While there's a brief mention of API integration, there's no dedicated homepage section showcasing the specific tools and platforms that BlueNotary integrates with. For businesses evaluating BlueNotary, integration with their existing tech stack is a major consideration and potential objection. If they can't easily see that BlueNotary works with their CRM, document management system, or other tools, they may abandon the evaluation process.

Create a dedicated "Integrations" section on the homepage that displays logos of the key platforms and tools that BlueNotary integrates with. This section should include:

The current FAQ section addresses basic questions about how online notarization works, but it doesn't tackle the deeper objections and concerns that B2B buyers typically have, such as security, compliance, pricing, and implementation.

Expand the FAQ section to include questions that address common objections specific to your different buyer personas. Based on our past audits of B2B SaaS companies, here are some questions you should consider adding:

By addressing these objections proactively in the FAQ, you remove barriers to conversion and provide the reassurance that skeptical buyers need.

While there's a brief explanation in the FAQ about how online notarization works, there's no dedicated, visually engaging "How It Works" section on the homepage. For a service that may be unfamiliar to many users, clearly explaining the process is crucial for reducing anxiety and building confidence.

Create a dedicated "How It Works" section on the homepage that breaks down the notarization process into simple, visual steps. For example:

The pricing page has some good elements (clear pricing, no hidden fees), but it could be optimized further to reduce friction and increase conversions. The toggle switches and seat sliders may create confusion, and there's an opportunity to add more social proof and objection handling directly on this page.

Make the following improvements to the pricing page:

These changes will make the pricing page feel less overwhelming and more trustworthy, increasing the likelihood of conversion.

The pricing page clearly outlines the different plans and features, but it lacks social proof and tools to help potential customers quantify the value of BlueNotary. At this critical decision-making stage, buyers are looking for reassurance and a clear justification for the investment.

Enhance the pricing page by adding the following elements:

The current layout on both the homepage and the pricing page, while containing valuable information, makes it difficult for visitors to quickly scan and absorb the most critical information. Key outcomes and data points, such as "$450+ saved per e-closing transaction," "80% fewer errors," and "20k+ certified online notaries," are presented in a way that they can be easily missed. Similarly, the pricing page is unintuitive and hard to scan due to the multiple toggles and complex structure, which can lead to confusion and decision fatigue.

Restructure the layout of the homepage and pricing page to improve scannability and create a clear visual hierarchy that guides the user's attention to the most important information.

Andrew, I hope this audit was helpful! These optimization points are based off what I can visibly see on your website and will be a great start to optimizing your website for demos. But to reliably increase your website conversion rates beyond 30%+ I recommend these next steps:

•Analyze GA4 to identify which pages and features have influenced the most conversions and which product related topics your visitors engage the most with.

•Use heatmaps to identify which areas on your website visitors are dropping off and which areas are causing them to engage.

•Map out your competitive landscape and identify differentiators that you can use for your website’s messaging.

•Analyze third party customer reviews and identify the common themes that appear on positive reviews (emphasize these throughout the website) and negative reviews - use these as objection handling elements.